2) Market concentration – magnificent or risky?
The so-called ‘Magnificent 7’ technology stocks in the US have a cumulative weight of around 35% of the S&P 500. Some commentators have speculated that these elevated levels of index concentration are a precursor to a market correction.
Again, we disagree.
Concentration risk matters if investors are over-exposed to a single source of revenue. But many of the ‘Magnificent 7’ are conglomerates, each housing a number of different revenue streams and subsidiaries. These include cloud services, online retail, social media apps, application stores and video streaming.
Conceptually, if each of these subsidiaries were independent, superficial index concentration would be materially lower as 20 or 30 companies, not seven, would comprise 35% of the S&P 500. However, an investor would still be exposed to the same underlying businesses.
Concentration risk is therefore less of a concern when supported by diverse sources of revenue.
3) Profitability under pressure
High valuations could necessitate strong profit margins. If those elevated margins revert to historical averages, earnings could shrink, making current equity prices harder to justify.
Companies have enjoyed decades of rising margins thanks to low interest rates, global supply chains and tech efficiencies. Some of those tailwinds are reversing – higher labour and energy costs, geopolitical tensions and elevated interest rates now pose challenges.
However, comparing today’s profit margins to historical averages is a fraught exercise. Structural economic shifts have migrated value from tangible assets, such as railroads and commodities, to intangible assets such as technology.
An example of the demise of tangible assets is oil, which was once the lifeblood of economic expansion but has seen its grip loosen dramatically over the past few decades. The chart below shows the steep rise of GDP generated over the years from the same, fixed quantity of energy produced.
Intangible assets, on the other hand, are the order of the day, and they can produce greater margin resilience because usually just a few firms dominate. For example, within social media, consumers typically value larger, active communities, which makes it likely that a small number of larger companies will prevail.